**"It's not like adults can somehow be tested in advance to see if they are psychologically prepared to only take physical discipline so far and then stop—such as a swat on the butt with an open hand."**
This is important. Adults who know they have an issue with temper should be extremely mindful when they develop parenting techniques for their children, like a therapist at Solomon Counseling Center told me--but what about those who are unaware or in denial? It's not a fool proof method at all and completely shuts down the "line between discipline and child abuse" argument for corporal punishment.
To clarify, a zygote is formed when an egg is fertilized. "Fertilized-egg" is a term then used to illustrate to readers what a zygote is. That's how it's used here.
In response to scientific evidence: "The fact that conception begins the life of a human being is an established scientific fact. There's no question-begging when the evidence is quite clear."
Biologically a human begins its growth at conception -- that is true and in my understanding, no one contests this. But when defining conception as the beginning of the life of a "person" we are moving into a moral realm, in which biology cannot be used as an argument. It is this moral argument -- that a "fertilized-egg" is a person -- that Personhood supporters must prove. The claim above, that conception is the beginning of biological human life, does not, in my understanding, support Personhood.
AnnaWolfe says...
**"It's not like adults can somehow be tested in advance to see if they are psychologically prepared to only take physical discipline so far and then stop—such as a swat on the butt with an open hand."**
This is important. Adults who know they have an issue with temper should be extremely mindful when they develop parenting techniques for their children, like a therapist at Solomon Counseling Center told me--but what about those who are unaware or in denial? It's not a fool proof method at all and completely shuts down the "line between discipline and child abuse" argument for corporal punishment.
On Why Do Children Stay?
Posted 8 October 2014, 1:19 p.m. Suggest removal
AnnaWolfe says...
To clarify, a zygote is formed when an egg is fertilized. "Fertilized-egg" is a term then used to illustrate to readers what a zygote is. That's how it's used here.
In response to scientific evidence: "The fact that conception begins the life of a human being is an established scientific fact. There's no question-begging when the evidence is quite clear."
Biologically a human begins its growth at conception -- that is true and in my understanding, no one contests this. But when defining conception as the beginning of the life of a "person" we are moving into a moral realm, in which biology cannot be used as an argument. It is this moral argument -- that a "fertilized-egg" is a person -- that Personhood supporters must prove. The claim above, that conception is the beginning of biological human life, does not, in my understanding, support Personhood.
Thanks for discussion!
On ‘Personhood’ May Be Back
Posted 22 March 2014, 10:48 p.m. Suggest removal